Safe Harbor Seafood

Sheepshead is a flavorful, mild white fish known for its firm texture and fresh, clean taste. Caught locally in North Florida, from the Intracoastal waterways to offshore reefs in the western Atlantic, this prized fish is as fresh as it gets. Its moist, flaky fillets are perfect for grilling, baking, or pan-searing. With its delicate taste, Sheepshead pairs well with a variety of seasonings and sauces, making it a versatile choice for any seafood lover. Enjoy this locally sourced favorite for a delicious and satisfying meal. *Please note that our pricing is based on the whole fish, including for fillets. You will be charged for the total weight of the fish needed to prepare the fillets.* Wild Caught ✅

Sheepshead is a flavorful, mild white fish known for its firm texture and fresh, clean taste. Caught locally in North Florida, from the Intracoastal waterways to offshore reefs in the western Atlantic, this prized fish is as fresh as it gets. Its moist, flaky fillets are perfect for grilling, baking, or pan-searing. With its delicate taste, Sheepshead pairs well with a variety of seasonings and sauces, making it a versatile choice for any seafood lover. Enjoy this locally sourced favorite for a delicious and satisfying meal.*Please note that our pricing is based on the whole fish, including for fillets. You will be charged for the total weight of the fish needed to prepare the fillets.*Wild Caught ✅

Sheepshead

Fillet (Skin-on)

Fillet (Skin-off)

Head on, Scaled, Gutted

Head Off, Scaled, Gutted

Head On, Scaled, Gutted, Split

Head Off, Scaled, Gutted, Split

Pickup Order InstructionsWhen you arrive at the store, please notify any employee at the cash register that you are here to pick up an online order. The cashier will inform the team behind the market.Next, walk to the right side of the display case, where your order will be ready for pickup. No need to wait in line!If you have any questions, feel free to ask any staff member for assistance. If you're unable to arrive during your selected pickup window, please be aware that we cannot guarantee your order will be held if another customer purchases it in person. We recommend arriving on time or giving us a call 30 minutes in advance if you need to adjust your pickup window—we’re happy to help!

Store Pickup

Please choose a time window in which you would like to receive your delivery. A majority of items are packed in an insulated cooler with plenty of ice. For items such as live crawfish or oysters, please select a time window in which you will be available to receive the delivery.

Delivery

Shipping

Pick up from the shrimp stand to the left of the market outside of the wholesale front door.

Monday Marketplace pickup

Safe Harbor Seafood Local Delivery

Safe Harbor Seafood Market is the culmination of years of experience you only get in a family business&nbsp;We are proud to offer the best local seafood in Mayport, Florida and the surrounding areas. Stop in and dine, order catering or purchase fresh fish to cook your own delicious meals. We can’t wait to satiate your craving for fresh, delicious fish and shellfish straight from the sea.

Safe Harbor Seafood Market is the culmination of years of experience you only get in a family business We are proud to offer the best local seafood in Mayport, Florida and the surrounding areas. Stop in and dine, order catering or purchase fresh fish to cook your own delicious meals. We can’t wait to satiate your craving for fresh, delicious fish and shellfish straight from the sea.

All orders for local seafood home delivery must be placed by 5:00 PM for next-day delivery. Orders can also be scheduled up to seven days in advance, but fulfillment is subject to product availability. In the event of any issues with your order, such as item unavailability, our team will contact you promptly to discuss alternatives or adjustments.We appreciate your understanding and look forward to serving you the freshest seafood Mayport has to offer!

Our delivery zone details can be found on the Service Locations page. Home delivery and pick-up is available from Wednesday to Sunday for orders placed by 5 pm one day in advance.If you prefer to pick up your order, we offer store pickup at our location:4371 Ocean St, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233Feel free to choose the option that works best for you!

When you place an order, we place a hold for a slightly higher order total on your card. This pending hold is replaced by the correct charge upon successful packing and delivery. This ensures that suppliers can charge accurate weights for products (i.e. 1.09lb or 0.98lb fish fillet vs. 1lb ordered). If you cancel the order or the payment hold is not captured, the authorization is cancelled and the funds are released back. It&#39;s very similar to the gas pump!

You can cancel your order up until the order cutoff time before delivery or pick up. Because our team starts very early in the morning, we are not able to accommodate changes to your order on the day of delivery.

We cannot accept returns or cancellations the same day of your order but we will do our best to address any issue with your order. You can cancel or change your order up until the cutoff hour for your service region.

Gift cards that are bought online or sent as a gift can only be used to purchase items online for pick up or delivery from the seafood market. Giftcards purchased in store at the market or restaurant may be used in person. 

Consumer AdvisoryConsuming raw oysters or shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, particularly for individuals with weakened immune systems. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) caution that raw oysters and shellfish can contain harmful bacteria or viruses that can cause severe illness in vulnerable individuals.

Have a question? We have answers. Here are some common ones: What are your order cutoff times? All orders for local seafood home delivery must be placed by 5:00 PM for next-day delivery. Orders can also be scheduled up to seven days in advance, but fulfillment is subject to product availability. In the event of any issues with your order, such as item unavailability, our team will contact you promptly to discuss alternatives or adjustments.We appreciate your understanding and look forward to serving you the freshest seafood Mayport has to offer!, Where do you deliver? Do you have pickup locations? Our delivery zone details can be found on the Service Locations page. Home delivery and pick-up is available from Wednesday to Sunday for orders placed by 5 pm one day in advance.If you prefer to pick up your order, we offer store pickup at our location:4371 Ocean St, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233Feel free to choose the option that works best for you!, Why do I see a pre-authorization / payment hold on my statement? When you place an order, we place a hold for a slightly higher order total on your card. This pending hold is replaced by the correct charge upon successful packing and delivery. This ensures that suppliers can charge accurate weights for products (i.e. 1.09lb or 0.98lb fish fillet vs. 1lb ordered). If you cancel the order or the payment hold is not captured, the authorization is cancelled and the funds are released back. It&#39;s very similar to the gas pump!, Why do I see a pre-authorization / payment hold on my statement? You can cancel your order up until the order cutoff time before delivery or pick up. Because our team starts very early in the morning, we are not able to accommodate changes to your order on the day of delivery., etc.

Shop Safe Harbor Seafood

Sheepshead

Sheepshead

Safe Harbor Seafood

Contact